Note: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click and buy, I may earn a small commission at no cost to you. I only recommend what I use and trust.
Fish oil supplements are everywhere—touted as miracle pills for your heart, brain, joints, and mood. But once you strip away the marketing, is it actually worth taking?
This post cuts through the hype. You’ll learn what fish oil really does, who might benefit, who probably won’t, and why I personally stopped using it. Spoiler: it had nothing to do with effectiveness and everything to do with oxidation risk and acid reflux. I’ll also walk you through cleaner, safer alternatives that might make more sense depending on your needs.
What Fish Oil Supplements Actually Are
Fish oil is made by extracting fat from oily fish like sardines, anchovies, mackerel, and salmon. The key active ingredients are omega-3 fatty acids:
- EPA (Eicosapentaenoic Acid) – supports inflammation regulation
- DHA (Docosahexaenoic Acid) – essential for brain and cell membrane health
Most standard fish oil softgels contain around 300–500 mg combined EPA and DHA per 1000 mg capsule unless you’re buying highly concentrated formulas.
Why Everyone Started Taking It
Fish oil’s rise started decades ago with studies on cardiovascular health and inflammation. Since then, it’s been marketed for:
- Lowering triglycerides
- Supporting heart health
- Reducing joint pain
- Improving brain function
- Helping with depression and mood disorders
That’s a wide net—and it helped turn fish oil into a multi-billion-dollar industry. But not all claims hold up.
What the Science Actually Says
Backed by Evidence:
Lowering high triglycerides (especially at high doses: 2–4 g/day EPA+DHA)
Prenatal support: DHA is important for fetal brain development
Some anti-inflammatory effects, mainly from EPA
Overhyped or Inconsistent:
Heart attack and stroke prevention in the average person
General cognitive enhancement in healthy adults
Mood and depression: only modest benefit in some, mostly EPA-dominant
Arthritis pain: results vary; not everyone sees relief
Why I Quit Taking Fish Oil
I didn’t stop because it didn’t “work.” I stopped because of how unstable and irritating it became.
- Oxidation risk: Fish oil turns rancid easily. Unless it’s processed and stored under strict conditions (and you refrigerate it), there’s a good chance you’re swallowing oxidized fats—which can do more harm than good. Most brands don’t publish oxidation data or freshness testing.
- Acid reflux: Even high-quality softgels caused reflux and burping. If you already deal with GERD or have sensitive digestion, fish oil can be a trigger. In my case, it definitely was.
Bottom line: the side effects weren’t worth it. There are cleaner ways to support the same health goals.
Who Might Still Benefit
Fish oil isn’t useless. It still makes sense in certain situations:
- People with very high triglycerides (under medical supervision)
- Pregnant women needing DHA for fetal development
- Those with inflammation-related conditions who don’t get enough omega-3s from food
- People with limited access to real fish
Who Should Be Cautious
You may want to skip fish oil or look at alternatives if:
You’re just taking it “because everyone does” without a clear reason
You experience acid reflux, burping, or GI discomfort
You already eat fatty fish 2–3 times per week
You’re concerned about oxidation or product freshness
You’re on blood thinners or have a fish allergy
Alternatives That Might Make More Sense
If you want the benefits of omega-3s without the risk of fishy burps or rancid oil, these are smarter picks:
1. Algal Oil (Plant-Based EPA/DHA)
A clean, plant-based source of DHA (and sometimes EPA). No fish, no burps, no oxidation if it’s stored well. Ideal for vegans and anyone with reflux issues.
Dosage: 300–600 mg/day combined
What to Look For: Third-party tested, made in closed-system tanks
2. Krill Oil
Some find it easier to digest than standard fish oil. It contains phospholipid-bound omega-3s plus astaxanthin (a natural antioxidant).
Dosage: 500–1000 mg/day
What to Look For: Sustainably harvested, tested for heavy metals and oxidation
3. Ground Flax or Chia Seeds
These provide ALA, a plant omega-3 that your body can convert (poorly) into EPA/DHA. Not a direct replacement, but better than nothing—especially for inflammation support.
Dosage: 1–2 tbsp/day
What to Look For: Fresh-ground or cold-pressed, store in fridge
4. Real Fish (2–3x Weekly)
Whole food is always best. Sardines, salmon, anchovies, and mackerel are rich in EPA and DHA.
Tip: Avoid larger fish like tuna or swordfish due to mercury.
Bottom Line
Fish oil isn’t the miracle it was sold as, and for some of us, it’s just not worth the side effects. I quit because of the risk of oxidation and constant acid reflux, not because I doubted the science.
If you’re using it for a legitimate reason—like high triglycerides or DHA during pregnancy—it can still be useful. Just make sure you’re using third-party tested, fresh, high-EPA or balanced formulas, and not just grabbing the cheapest bottle on the shelf.
If you’re like me and it causes more problems than it solves, there are solid alternatives that can give you similar benefits without the downsides.